2012 Pulitzer Prizes

The 2012 Pulitzer Prizes

We had chosen all of these books as favorites last year. Read on to see our reviews for the Fiction nominees, and Non-Fiction and Poetry winners. We also have added selected commentators' perspectives about the judges' controversial decision to decline to name a Fiction winner. Maureen Corrigan offered what we thought were very reasonable suggestions

If the board, which received our three nominations in early December, is unhappy with the jury’s choices, then why not request that the jury put forward alternative selections?

And, finally, how about changing the rules so that the winner is determined by a plurality, rather than a majority of votes on the board. (And — Hello! — given that there are 18 voting members of the Pulitzer board, perhaps one more body should be added to break any potential ties.)

Maureen Corrigan of Georgetown University and Fresh Air in The Washington Post

Susan Larson of NPR in the Christian Science Monitor 

Lev Grossman in Time Magazine

Ann Patchett in The New Yorker 

What do you think? Add your comment below.

  

Fiction

National Book Award-winner Denis Johnson’s compact and intense Train Dreams (Farrar, Straus and Giroux, $18) tells the story of Robert Granier, who spent his life from the early 1900s through the early 1960s working on lumber crews in Idaho and Montana. After losing his wife and daughter in a fire, Granier led a mostly solitary life homesteading and dealing with the enormous changes taking place around him, such as the advent of the automobile and the airplane. Rather than tell the story of a man’s life in exhaustive detail, Johnson captures the totality of Granier’s life by detailing just a few experiences over the course of his lifetime. Granier never lets go of the tragic deaths of his wife and daughter, and their passing merges in his mind with local folklore. Johnson’s character study reveals the essence of an ordinary man, and in that very ordinariness lies his glory. Mark LaFramboise

$18.00
ISBN-13: 9780374281144
Availability: On Our Shelves Now
Published: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 9/2011

Ava wants to wrestle alligators like her mother, Hilola Bigtree. Her sister Ossie, short for Osseola, is in love with a ghost. Her brother Kiwi has left home to work for the Bible themed amusement Park on the mainland. The plot is a bit eccentric, but the story of the Bigtree family should be recognizable to anyone who is part of an even slightly unusual family (and who isn’t). Full of imagination, humor and heartbreak, Swamplandia! by Karen Russell (Vintage, $14.95) ranges the gamut of emotions from stunned silence to belly laughs. –- Mark LaFramboise


Swamplandia! (Paperback)

$14.95
ISBN-13: 9780307276681
Availability: On Our Shelves Now
Published: Vintage, 7/2011

The Pale King, by the late David Foster Wallace (Little, Brown, $27.99; Back Bay, $16.99), stretched the possibilities of the novel as a genre and conveyed humanity upon even the faceless drones in the hated Internal Revenue Service. It was meant to be as ambitious an undertaking as his earlier 1000-page Infinite Jest, and while the book lacks his usual complexity and leaves aspects of the plot unfinished, for most of his audience the form and style will be entirely familiar, incomplete only in the perfection for which David was striving. Through these fragments, Wallace’s skill shines through in two central themes: the desire to find heroic purpose even in the tedium of ordinary life, and the struggle to see beyond one’s own blinkered perspective to connect with one's fellow human beings. – Andrew Getman

 


The Pale King (Paperback)

$16.99
ISBN-13: 9780316074223
Availability: On Our Shelves Now
Published: Back Bay Books, 4/2012

Poetry
The winner of this year’s Pulitzer Prize for poetry, Life on Mars (Graywolf, $15), by Tracy K. Smith, is poetry with a David Bowie soundtrack, While sampling some of Bowie’s lyrics, Smith’s third collection is a deftly crafted, thoughtful consideration of existence on Earth and beyond. In lines at once musical and muscular, Smith has composed an extended elegy for her father, who worked on the Hubble telescope. As matters of science, grief, and faith inform each other, Smith wonders ”is God being or pure force? The wind / or what commands it?”; in other poems she uses vivid cosmic imagery to speculate on whether loss of a life here is balanced by the existence of life out there. - Laurie Greer


Life on Mars: Poems (Paperback)

$15.00
ISBN-13: 9781555975845
Availability: On Our Shelves Now
Published: Graywolf Press, 4/2011

History

Encyclopedic in its approach, Manning Marable’s Malcolm X: A Life of Reinvention (Viking, $30; Penguin, $18) provides the most comprehensive and penetrating portrait yet of the legendary black activist. Marable, a historian who died on the eve of this book’s publication, drew on diaries, letters, FBI and CIA documents, and interviews with people who had been silent for decades. He peels away the layers of myth that have arisen around Malcolm as a result of Malcolm’s own memoir and the efforts of both supporters and opponents after his assassination in 1965 at the age of 39. The result is a biography that meticulously charts the complex and contradiction-filled evolution of Malcolm’s political and religious beliefs and also sets Malcolm’s life within the larger context of 20th-century racial developments. Bradley Graham


$18.00
ISBN-13: 9780143120322
Availability: On Our Shelves Now
Published: Penguin (Non-Classics), 1/2012

Biography

In George F. Kennan: An American Life (Penguin Press, $39.95), John Lewis Gaddis looks into the life of the man credited with the creation of America’s foreign policy during the Cold War. George Kennan is best known for the “Long Telegram” and “X Article” which set forth the strategy of containment that America adopted with considerable success. This period in American international relations has been dissected at length, but Gaddis’s is the first book to discuss Kennan’s personal life. Drawing on private journals and countless interviews, Gaddis profiles the man behind the policies with the detail and compassion that are essential to any biography. Jenny Clines


$39.95
ISBN-13: 9781594203121
Availability: On Our Shelves Now
Published: Penguin Press HC, The, 11/2011

General Nonfiction

The world into which Lucretius’s On the Nature of Things was reborn in 1417 felt threatened by the ideas expressed there. But The Swerve: How the World Became Modern (W.W. Norton, $26.95) history took in this event, from a God-centered to a material conception of the universe, influenced subsequent thinkers and changed the course of Western culture. In his riveting and suspenseful story of those ideas and their rediscovery, the eminent scholar Stephen Greenblatt, author of the popular Will in the World, recounts how Poggio Bracciolini, a canny and ruthless papal apparatchik, but also an intrepid book hunter with exquisite handwriting, found the only surviving copy of this classical masterpiece secreted in a remote German monastery. Greenblatt, himself heir to the humanistic turn effected by the surfacing of On the Nature of Things, has made narrative central to our understanding of literature and culture and unfailingly finds anecdotes that catch the reflected light of an entire cosmos.


$26.95
ISBN-13: 9780393064476
Availability: On Our Shelves Now
Published: W. W. Norton & Company, 9/2011